Thin Mint Whoopie Pies

Posted by on Mar 7, 2012 in Desserts | 12 Comments

Somewhere in the rhythm of morning, Colleen started to relax.

For years, when the alarm first shot awake in the dark, Colleen would squeeze her eyes shut and wish for another life, one that did not see her waking in the middle of the damned night. All she wanted was sleep.

Sometimes, she would drop her face into her pillow and let out a scream. The first time she did that, Mark awoke beside her with a start. Eventually though, he got used to the trilling sound of her alarm and her pitched response, the way she would flop angrily beside him like a caught flounder. The first time he slept through it all, Colleen had sat up in bed and stared down at him, amazed at the rise and fall of his chest, the steadiness of his breathing. He would have hours, glorious whole hours, before having to wake himself. She pushed him off the bed.

There was no music in the kitchen. It was damp outside and the dark street that led to her door smelled like rain. In time, real light would trickle in but for now, the kitchen hummed with an unnatural, yellowish glow.

It had taken 1,457 days, nearly four years of mornings, but now Colleen stopped in her kitchen. Her hands, caked in chocolate dust and spots of rose, stopped their movements, their rhythm broken. She nudged aside the spoons and bowls and placed her palms on the old wood board that served as her table. The grittiness of the sugar sank into her open palms. In one of her ovens, a round loaf of bread chose that moment to crack its top and its warm, yeasty smell bloomed in the air. She stopped and let it fill her lungs, let it fill everything.

My mother had a way with a sewing needle.

When we were young, she made our Halloween costumes. When we grew older, we drifted toward the traditional (cheerleader, hobo, etc. Now that I think of it, Hobo Cheerleader would be an exceptional costume) but the ones that stand out most in old pictures are the ones that she made by hand- my sisters dressed up as the Ingalls, crayons, M&Ms. My personal favorite was her Devil Dog costume.  A Devil Dog, just in case you’ve never had the pleasure or didn’t grow up with Drakes Cakes, is basically a stretched out whoopie pie.

I’m pretty sure this is how food bloggers are born. (The WordPress fairies fall into a hushed silence. “Do you hear that?” the fairy coos. “Somewhere, a chubby child is being wrestled into a macaron costume. What will he write one day?” she wonders. “Quick, get thee a template!”)

I wanted to make these confections for three reasons: 1) My Girl Scout cookies are scheduled to be delivered on St. Patrick’s Day (thank you to my niece Hannah for being a Brownie and thus making all of my aunt-related dreams come true), 2) Thin Mints are both delicious and appropriately tinted for the Irish celebration and 3) Mint Chocolate Chip is a favorite of my sister’s and she’s having a Purplicious Birthday Party for her three-year old daughter on St. Patrick’s Day, Corinne’s birthday. (They’re not purple but anyone hosting a dozen children in their home deserves a special treat and I didn’t think we could get away with some artfully photographed handfuls of Valium.)

Nieces! Things that are green! Girl Scout Cookies! So many things overlapping. How could we not make Thin Mint Whoopie Pies? They practically made themselves.

Thin Mint Whoopie Pies

Adapted from Gourmet (Jan. 2003) and Simply Recipes | Yields: 8 Servings | Total Time: 1 hr 30 min | Print Recipe

Note: Cakes can be made three days ahead and kept at room temperature. Store in an airtight container and layer between wax paper.


For cakes

2 Cups of all-purpose flour
1/2 Cup of Dutch-process cocoa powder
1 and 1/4 Teaspoons of baking soda
1 Teaspoon of salt
1 Cup of well-shaken buttermilk
1 Teaspoon of vanilla
1 Stick (1/2 Cup) of unsalted butter, softened
1 Cup of packed brown sugar
1 Large egg

For filling

8 TBsps of butter, room temperature
1 TBp of milk
1/4 to 1/2 Teaspoon of peppermint extract
2 Cups of powdered sugar

Chocolate chips (optional)


1. Preheat oven to 350 F. Butter two large baking sheets.

2. In a bowl, whisk together the flour, cocoa, baking soda and salt until combined.

3. In a measuring cup, stir together the buttermilk and vanilla.

4. In a large bowl with an electric mixer, beat the butter and brown sugar at medium-high speed for about 3-5 minutes until pale and fluffy.

5. Add egg to sugar mixture and beat until well combined.

6. Reduce speed to low and alternately mix in flour mixture and vanilla buttermilk in batches, beginning and ending with flour. Occasionally, scrape down the sides of the bowl and mix until smooth. Do not overmix.

7. Spoon mounds of batter (use a 1/4 cup) onto buttered baking sheets, about 2 inches apart.

8. Bake in upper and lower thirds of oven for 11 to 13 minutes, rotating pans once halfway through baking. Tops should be puffed and the cakes should spring back when touched.

9. Cool cakes completely on a rack.

10. Make buttercream filling: In an electric mixer, beat the butter at medium speed until creamy. Beat in milk and mint extract.

11. Slowly add in the powdered sugar on low speed, stopping every now and then to scrape down sides, until filling is light and fluffy. Add more mint or powdered sugar, to taste. We ended by folding in some chocolate chips.

12. Assemble whoopie pies by spreading a rounded tablespoon of filling on flat sides of cakes and top with remaining cakes.


  1. Claire
    March 7, 2012

    I think I’d call these “fat mint whoopie pies”, they look like delightfully chubby versions of the girl scout cookie!

    • Nicole
      March 7, 2012

      lol, yes I think mini versions would be really cute and perfect size

  2. Tapas
    March 7, 2012


    That’s why you’re on of my favourite inspirations.
    I really inspire myself in your blog, to get my “food photography” better and better.
    Thank you so much!

    Keep up with the great blogging!

    • Nicole
      March 7, 2012

      Thanks! Glad you enjoy it 🙂

  3. Ambika
    March 8, 2012

    Yummy! LOVE everything about this whoppie pie!

  4. smileysoyabean
    March 11, 2012

    Thank you! These are the first whoopie pies I’ve tried making and they’ve turned out pretty well 🙂

  5. Daisy@Nevertoosweet
    March 12, 2012

    These whoopie pies looks amazing!!! But I’ve never had one before! Disgrace lol i’ve gotta make these sometime to try whoopie pies 😀

  6. Supersized whoopie pies « The Smiley Soyabean
    March 12, 2012

    […] I’ve been thinking about some sort of mint cupcake for a while, so when I spotted this recipe I decided I had to have a […]

  7. Amy
    March 14, 2012

    Just discovered your blog on Pinterest, I love it! Look forward to reading your future posts, Amy Xxx

  8. Honey Walnut Banana Bread Recipe Some Kitchen Stories Honey Walnut Banana Bread Recipe | 1 Photographer. 1 Writer. This is Our Food Blog.
    April 27, 2012

    […] were filled with her wares, bright and clashing in color and height and perfect.Her friend Colleen, who owned the bakery next door, had surprised her with a tray of thinly sliced pieces of warm […]

  9. b
    May 10, 2014

    Cakes flattened out a ton during baking. Ended up looking like medium chocolate pancakes. Used a star cutout to spin a pleasant appearance.

  10. Khate
    October 2, 2014

    Jill, I really aimrde your honesty about your adoption experience and raising your baby, T, he is adorable. I too have an adopted child, from China, a girl named Ellie and 4 biological daughters. Lots of hormones and lots of love and kisses at our house!My interest was peaked when you mentioned the term disrupted attachment . I have never heard this term before, but it sounds all too familiar to me, the distance that is maintained between the child and the parents, usually me, vacillating between acceptance and rejection, so painful for us, but probably a result of past female bonds in the orphanage. Is this definition correct? I have always imagined that my daughter Ellie is a survivor and after her being here with us for 6 years she is thriving and our relationship is great, but sometimes when I lean over to give her that goodnight kiss, I can still feel her hesitation.Bottom line all we can do is love our children, no matter their beginnings and I wish you all the best, you seem to be doing a great job being a momma!


Leave a Reply to Khate

Cancel Reply