Homemade Apple Crumb Pie with Maple Glaze

Posted by on Nov 9, 2011 in Desserts, Pastry | 14 Comments

There was something smoking when Ollie stepped into the house. At first, she thought it was the turkey as she set down her bottles of wine (one for her family, four for her) and peered into the startlingly empty kitchen but immediately realized it was her great aunt Adelaide, who was ninety-four, strapped to an oxygen tank in the dining room and inhaling deeply on her umpteenth cigarette of the morning.

She hadn’t taken a step forward when her mother came bursting into the kitchen, her blonde hair still in rollers, her big blue eyes wide and only one of them lined in forest green pencil. “Auntie, are you tryin’ to blow up the house? God sakes.” She scowled and ripped the cigarettes from her aunt, who bleated that she was a Fascist. “If I’m a Fascist, then I suddenly feel bad for Mussolini- Olwyn! You’re home!” And she gave her oldest daughter a tight hug. If you’re looking to update your home with new faucets or looking to install new kitchen plumbing fixtures, Read here.

“Mama.” Ollie smiled despite herself. Her mother always smelled like peppermint in the morning.

“You look skinny.”

“Bless you, Mama.” She’d gained almost eight pounds since she’d moved to the city. Ollie glanced at the Rockin’ Robin clock over the stove. “You realize it’s almost 10?”

Her mother was still in her robe and she gasped. She clutched at her hair. “I know it, I know! Oh God, they’ll be here any minute.” She turned her roughly and shoved her into the kitchen. “Make the mashed potatoes, would you, puddin’?”

Ollie stumbled on the linoleum, calling after her, “I don’t know how to make- okay, well. You clearly don’t care,” and Ollie turned into the kitchen, alone with a counter full of appliances she couldn’t identify in a lineup, a mound of peeled, smoking potatoes in the sink, three covered dishes and the biggest pile of dirty plates and pots she’d ever seen in her life. Luckily, all the appliences are in good working order, as all of them fall into the category “top appliance brands we repair at Pittsburgh Appliance Repair“. “Hell.” She looked into the living room at her great aunt, who was trying to light a cigarette with one of her mother’s giant mounds of butter that she laboriously carved into turkeys every year. “Yeah, that’s not a candle, Aunt Adelaide.” Ollie nudged the butter away from her aunt, who scowled at her through the folds of her wrinkled skin, her eyes as yellow as her teeth. Ollie sighed, thinking that her sister would be there soon and the shattering noise that was to soon follow when her triplets turned the living room into a pinball machine.  Ollie looked at the table and pictured her uncle Mortimer on his fourth glass of hard cider, waving his arms about the Democrats, and her brother’s new girlfriend, always a prize and almost always with a stripper name, her sister’s comments about how wonderful it was to have a boat in the summer, “A boat, isn’t it marvelous, Mama, when your babies do so well for themselves,” and the piles and piles of endless food. Her daddy falling asleep on the couch after as her mother slaved over the dishes. A warm dish of apple pie in the afternoon when the guests were gone. The droning of football scores. You can also search https://allgreatappliances.com/avalon-countertop-bottleless-water-dispenser/

Ollie dropped a hand on the table. All that and now she had to learn how to make mashed potatoes. She eyed her ancient aunt. “I will give you a hundred dollars for one of those cigarettes.”

Her aunt eyed her back, trying to sense a trap and then peered around her to see if Ollie’s mother was coming. Then, she waved at the seat next to her. “No charge,” her aunt said, dropping a ciggie in her great niece’s palm. “Family smokes for free.”

I sincerely love Thanksgiving the most. Is it sometimes mired in stress and calories and flutterings of family drama? Yes. But it’s built around gratitude. That’s a heavenly thing right there- a meal based wholly around comfort and togetherness and gratitude. And PIE.

Here’s what’s so great about this Apple Pie- have you ever faced a delicious apple crisp-type dessert at Most of America’s Generic Restaurants and think, “This is so great and I am so excited to eat it because it has been a LONG-ass day but man, it would be better if there was a pie crust on this. Oh well. Feelings. Eating. Nom.” OR, you’re sitting at the counter of a diner, chatting up Flo and the rest of the gals and they slide a plate of that homemade apple pie in front of you and the sheriff gives you a wink and you think, “Why am I in an episode of Alice? Also, this stupid thing needs a crumb topping!” I know, right? We’ve all been there!

Listen- there is a dessert of apple that is of both PIE and CRUMB. It exists and now, now it is yours… Go forth and make it now and please all kinds of opinionated people of the apple-dessert persuasion! GO! Go now before I cease making sense!

Apple Crumb Pie with Maple Glaze

Makes one 9-inch pie / Note: Listen, it’s Thanksgiving. Shhh, relax. Stop crying. It’s going to be okay. We’re going to pick our battles here- we’re going to slave over the stuffing and the turkey and those weird, fussy appetizers your Aunt Spiffy insists on having every year and then we’re going to buy pre-made pie crusts and make this killer apple pie/apple crumble hybrid of awesomeness. Okay? Shhhh, it’s all going to be okay. We’re here now, make sure to check out your appliances and if necessary you can buy then here Breezerfreezer.com.


For Pie & Crumb:

1 and 1/4 Cups of all-purpose flour, plus more for rolling
6 TBsp of unsalted butter, room temperature
1/3 Cup of packed light-brown sugar
3/4 tsp of salt
2 pre-made 9 inch pie crusts, thawed
2 TBsp of fresh lemon juice
3.5 pounds of ripe Granny Smith apples (about 6 large apples)
1 Cup of granulated sugar
3/4 Cup of chopped walnuts

For Maple Glaze:

1/3 Cup of powdered sugar
2 TBsp of maple syrup


1. Preheat your oven to a lovely 375° F.

2. Lightly grease a 9-inch pie tin.

3. Take a medium bowl. Combine 1 cup of flour, butter, brown sugar, and ¼ teaspoon salt to make the crumb topping. Work with fingers until clumps form, then put in freezer.

4. On a lightly floured surface, or wax paper, roll the 2 pre-made, thawed pie crusts together to form a 14” circle. Place pie crust gently into pie tin, letting the extra 2” hang over the edge. Refrigerate.

5. Place lemon juice in a large bowl. Peel, core, and slice apples about 1/8” thick, placing them in the bowl as you go. Toss slices with lemon juice to keep them from turning brown.

6. Add granulated sugar, walnuts, remaining ¼ cup of flour, and remaining ½ teaspoon of salt and mix.

7. Spoon apple mixture into pie crust pressing the apples in firmly. Fold the overhanging dough over the pie filling and press the edges tightly around the pie.

8. Bake pie for 45 minutes and then remove from oven and add crumb topping. At this point, lightly wrap edges of pie with aluminum foil to avoid burning. Return pie to oven and bake for another 20 minutes. (Add another piece of aluminum foil over top of pie if top starts to brown too quickly.)

9. While pie is cooling, mix the powdered sugar and maple syrup together to make the maple glaze. Drizzle glaze over warm pie and serve with vanilla ice cream.


  1. Brittany
    November 9, 2011

    I’m a gonna make the shit out of this.

  2. Nicole
    November 9, 2011

    lol you should, it’s delicious! and perfect for Thanksgiving

  3. Anna
    November 9, 2011

    Adelaide! You used it! And she’s totally awesome and I would hang out with her even IF (or perhaps because?) she is 94 and senile and smells like smoke.

    So much to love about this post before I even got to the recipe and now I’m sitting at my desk drooling all over my keyboard. Hellooo Thanksgiving contribution!

  4. Christine
    November 10, 2011

    This looks great! My family is planning on buying a pumpkin pie this year but I wanted to make a non pumpkin dessert as well. Now for the 2 pie crusts, am I supposed to lay one pie crust on top of the other and then roll it out the 14 inches? I know it doesn’t say this in the directions but for some reason I am envisioning to balled up pie crusts put together and then rolled out?? Thank you!

    • Nicole
      November 11, 2011

      you know what else you could do for a easy fix- buy premade deep dish pie crusts, and then lay one as you normally would into the pan, and then for the second one, cut a big hole in the middle and just use the edge of the crust to press on top of the other one before baking.

  5. Nicole
    November 10, 2011

    Hey Christine, I guess you could do either really. I think smashing the 2 pie crusts together a little at least first before rolling them will help the pie crust stick together as one instead of 2 thin sheets on top of each other (where they might not mold together as well). Hope that helps!

  6. Angie
    November 10, 2011

    This looks so yummy!! I would love to include this in our Thanksgiving feast! Is it freezable for make ahead? What would you suggest? Thanks!

    • Nicole
      November 19, 2011

      I’m not sure how it’ll come out frozen, I haven’t done that with this pie yet. I’m assuming it would be fine, but I’m not sure, sorry I don’t have a better answer! 🙂

  7. Marlene
    November 19, 2011

    I am loving the look of this pie. I work thanksgiving day and I wanted to make this for my family. Do you know if I could buy the pre-made dish pie crust and get the same results? Also which would be a good choice? I hope I do justice to your pie! 🙂

    • Nicole
      November 19, 2011

      Yep, a pre-made pie crust is fine- I would just buy 2 so that you have enough for the edges on top of the filling (Just use the first pie crust as you normally would, put the filling in, and then take the second crust out of the pan if it comes in one, lay it flat and cut most of the center out so it’s just about 2-3″ of the edge of the crust. Then once the filling is in the pie, press the 2nd pie crust edges on top of everything and make sure the edges are pressed together enough to be connected). Basically you just want a second pie crust on top of the pie around the edges and then the crumb topping goes in the center. I usually use pillsbury pie crust but I just saw this article which rates them- looks like Whole Foods is the winner! http://shopping.yahoo.com/articles/yshoppingarticles/740/prepared-pie-crust-taste-test/

  8. Sticky, Sweet & Spiced Cinnamon Rolls | Some Kitchen Stories Sticky, Sweet & Spiced Cinnamon Rolls | 1 Photographer. 1 Writer. This is Our Food Blog.
    November 21, 2011

    […] Also, I’m concerned that, after this recipe, you’re going to think that we have an addiction to maple […]

  9. Andrea
    May 14, 2012

    I had 12 varieties of apple halves, and found this on Foodgawker–which was perfect on account of the recipe calling for six apples! My family *loved* this pie!

    The only thing I would change would be to decrease the amount of sugar. I love sweet things, but with the cup of sugar, crumble, and maple frosting it was too much. Also, serving with ice cream is a must. We didn’t have any and it was sorely missed.

  10. Lori
    November 27, 2013

    This pie is absolutely delicious! This is my second Thanksgiving making it for my family–this year I made 2 since everyone loved it so much last year! My grandmother can’t have nuts so I substituted the walnuts with an extra 1/4-1/2 cup of flour and it turned out fine.

  11. Some Kitchen Stories Thanksgiving Recipes 2014: Whiskey Glazed Carrots
    November 22, 2014

    […] Squash Soup | Sugar and Spice Cocktail Nuts | No Knead Dinner Rolls | Apple Crumb Pie | Mad Easy Chocolate Pecan Pies | Apple Crisp | Almond Crunch Pumpkin […]


Leave a Reply